ProtectMyID Review – AAA Identity Theft – Is it Any Good?

Home Security Heroes independently tests and reviews every product. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. Read more here.

Most of us don’t act before it’s too late. You’ve probably been guilty of putting off important things too. Right?

Well, there are certain things that should never be put off. Your online security is one of them. This is especially true when you consider the fact that every other adult US citizen has experienced some form of online fraud or identity theft.

A decent identity theft protection service, ProtectMyID was among one of the least expensive ones we reviewed. But it can be quite limited for some. You should look elsewhere if you want other features for the same price.

  • They offer a $1 million insurance policy
  • Identity restoration help to pre-existing ID theft cases with the help of Privacy Advocates
  • Digital exposure reports
  • Proprietary monitoring mechanism
  • Up to 2 months free on an annual plan subscription
We would Choose Aura over ProtectID. Here’s Why:
The quick and dirty is that Aura overall provides a lot more bang for your buck across more categories:
  • Better Threat Resolution
  • More Accurate Monitoring
  • More Flexible Plan
  • Covers up to $5 million in lost funds
  • Excellent Antivirus & VPN Included

Get It Now and Enjoy OFF!


Even corporate behemoths and tech giants such as Google and Yahoo aren’t immune to such mishaps. So it makes perfect sense that you make your online security and that of your family a priority.       

Contrary to popular belief, you don’t have to be a tech nerd to maintain your online privacy and security and it’s won’t lighten your wallet too badly. Most ID theft protection services offer a wide range of plans to suit every need and budget.    

Today, let’s talk about identity theft and why it makes sense to put your online security into overdrive.  We’ll also look into a well-known identity protection service called ProtectMyID by Experian – so it’s easier for you to decide.    

But First, Why Should You Trust Us?

You can learn more about our testing process here.

The ABC of Identity Theft

What is it?

Any instance where an individual or an organization accesses and uses your sensitive personal or financial information for their advantage is called identity theft.

And for most people, it only gets more painful from there. One: it’s usually very difficult to find out who did it. And secondly, it’s not uncommon that illegal acts are committed with stolen identities.

Here’s Why Identity Protection is a MUST

Well, let’s not beat around the bush here. Changing your password every other month isn’t enough!

There are countless reasons why it makes sense to invest in a robust identity protection service. And the price you pay will pale in comparison with the peace of mind you’ll have after investing in protection.

Here’s how it’ll make your digital life a lot easier and safer.   

Continuous Monitoring

Your ID protection service will provide you with 24-7 monitoring of sensitive personal and financial information, such as your credit files and bank accounts. 

Timely Alerts

Every second after an identity breach can profoundly impact your odds of minimizing damage. Your protection service will provide you with prompt alerts and recovery measures in case of a hack. 

Information and Financial Restoration

This is where it really pays off. If an identity breach happens and you suffer financial loss as a result; your ID protection service will assist you with the entire restoration process. Most well-known services provide an ID theft insurance cover of up to $1 million.   

How to Choose the Best Identity Protection Service for YOU

Keep the following pointers in mind to choose a service that matches your needs.

1. Review Several Services
  • If you’re short on time, just check out what the top 5 ID protection services have to offer in terms of coverage, plans, prices, and the extent of security.
2. Pay attention to reviews
  • Don’t get sucked in by the fancy language! Make sure to do some thorough digging in the service’s review section. It’s the easiest way to find out if the service is worth your cash.
3. Transparency
  • Always ask questions to clarify your concerns. Their offer should be crystal clear. If you find it hard to understand, then there’s a good chance that something’s not right.
We would Choose Aura over ProtectID. Here’s Why:
The quick and dirty is that Aura overall provides a lot more bang for your buck across more categories:
  • Better Threat Resolution
  • More Accurate Monitoring
  • More Flexible Plan
  • Covers up to $5 million in lost funds
  • Excellent Antivirus & VPN Included

Get It Now and Enjoy OFF!


AAA ProtectMyID vs Experian ProtectMyID

What is AAA ProtectMyID?

AAA stands for American Automobile Association. It was established in 1902 as a nonprofit organization and cur rently has close 60 million members across the United States and Canada. Although AAA provides several services, it is mainly known for roadside assistance.

Now, AAA has teamed up with Experian to provide its members with identity protection services, hence the term AAA ProtectMyID. You can be sure of its reliability as Experian is one of the top credit monitoring agencies out there and is trusted by millions.

What is Experian ProtectMyID?

Experian ProtectMyID offers essentially the same set of ID protection services when you directly sign up from the Experian website. The difference, however, comes when you compare the plans.

Experian ProtectMyID offers 3 plans which are further divided into 2 tiers; Plus and Premium and prices range from $9.99 to 29.99 a month.

That’s not the case with AAA ProtectMyID. Although it offers 3 plans as well, there are no further sub-divisions. And the pricing structure is simpler too.      

Experian ProtectMyID – What Does it Offer?


ProtectMyID is relatively young in the ID theft protection arena. However, it still manages to punch above its weight.

Why? To start off, Experian owns and operates ProtectMyID, which is a definite plus considering its track record  It matters because Experian is one of the top credit monitoring agencies out there trusted by millions. Plus there are plenty of positive ProtectMyID customer reviews.

Here’s what you can expect after signing up with the service.

The key features include social network monitoring, SSN monitoring, dark web surveillance, daily detection scans, address safeguard, bank account, and credit card monitoring, identity validation alerts, payday loan monitoring, court records monitoring, sex offender registry, file sharing network monitoring, credit bureaus monitoring and daily Experian credit score.          

Here’s a primer on some of its key features:
Daily Detection
  • You will receive daily identity risk reports
Dark Web Scan
  • Experian will comb through the dark web to find out if your sensitive information is up for sale.
Address Safeguard
  • It will make sure your address doesn’t get changed without your knowledge.
$1 Million Identity Theft Insurance
  • Depending on the plan, you will be eligible for an identity theft insurance cover of up to $1 million.
Social Network Monitoring
  • Your social media profile is one of the easiest targets for hackers. Experian will keep you safe there as well.
Lost Wallet Assistance
  • You won’t have to cancel every single card if you lose your wallet. Experian ProtectMyID makes the entire process quick and easy.
Bank Account and Credit Card Takeovers
  • Bank accounts and cards are prime cut for any hacker. You will get a prompt ProtectMyID surveillance alert in case of unauthorized access.
Identity Validation Alerts
  • You will also receive alerts in case your identity is used for activities such as account opening or signing up with a business.
Payday Loan Monitoring
  • Experian will notify you if any loans are drawn in your name.
Court Records and Bookings
  • Experian ProtectMyID will let you know if any illegal activity is being associated with your name through court record tempering.
  • It’s owned and run by Experian, which means you can be sure of its reliability
  • It’s easy on your wallet – starts at $9.99 a month
  • Up to $1 million insurance coverage
  • User-friendly website
  • If needed, they will assign you an exclusive identity restoration official
  • Lower tier plan offers no more than bare-bones ID theft protection
  • The sign-up process may take a while and is relatively confusing

Pricing and Plans

Individual Plan Cost

  • FREE/m for AAA members ESSENTIAL

  • $10.95/m DELUXE

  • $15.95/m PLATINUM

Couple Plan Cost

  • No Couples plan

Family Plan Cost

  • $10.95/m DELUXE

  • $15.95/m PLATINUM

Renewal Price Increased After 1st Year?

  • No

ProtectMyID offers 3 plans. All three plans are divided into 2 tiers; Deluxe and Platinum. While the Plus tier offers basic coverage, the Platinum tier offers a much more comprehensive list of features.

It’s important to know that after signing up with ProtectMyID you will be redirected to the Experian IdentityWorks page.

The plans start from $10.95 a month and are priced up to $15.95 a month depending on the features and whether it’s an individual plan or a family plan. You can take advantage of the 30-day free trial with all the plans and canceling your membership is also quite easy.

Moreover, ProtectMyID offers a generous bulk discount if you make an annual payment. You save up to 17% on annual payments.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How much does ProtectMyID plans cost?

Prices may vary according to what plan you’re getting. Plus protection plans range from $9.99 up to $19.99 which comprises individual to family plans. Premium plans range from $19.99 up to $29.99 which includes individual to family plans.

2. Is ProtectMyID offered to everyone?

No, the company offers this protection plan exclusively to AAA members.

3. Is ProtectMyID worth it?

Yes, ProtectMyID is one of the best service providers in this industry and also insures you up to $1 million in case you become a victim of identity theft.

Final Score: 8/10

All in all, Experian ProtectMyID offers a decent security package. It’s especially great for large families that are on the lookout for reliable online security that doesn’t break the bank. One drawback though that particularly stands out is that its basic plan lacks the punch as compared to basic plans of some of the other options.    

We would Choose Aura over ProtectID. Here’s Why:
The quick and dirty is that Aura overall provides a lot more bang for your buck across more categories:
  • Better Threat Resolution
  • More Accurate Monitoring
  • More Flexible Plan
  • Covers up to $5 million in lost funds
  • Excellent Antivirus & VPN Included

Get It Now and Enjoy OFF!


Let’s compare ProtectMyID to other services:

Last Updated on